Can I Put Compost on Top of Soil?

 The Benefits of Adding Compost to Your Garden Soil: Top Dressing vs. Tilling

You can put compost on top of the soil, as top dressing provides a number of benefits such as improved soil structure, nutrient availability, and water retention without disrupting the existing soil ecosystem as tilling does.‍

Image Source: Unsplash‍

Introduction

The soil is the foundation of a successful garden, and its fertility is essential for growing strong plants. Maintaining healthy soil should be a top concern for any gardener since the soil is a complex ecosystem that supports plant development. One of the best methods to improve soil health is composting. I'll discuss the benefits of incorporating compost into your garden soil in this article, along with the two most popular techniques, top dressing and tilling.

Top Dressing vs. Tilling

Definition and explanation of top dressing and tilling

Top dressing is the process of applying a layer of compost over the soil surface without disturbing it. It is a method of adding organic matter to the soil without tilling or digging. Top dressing helps to improve soil fertility, structure, and water retention while reducing erosion. On the other hand, tilling is the process of breaking up and loosening the soil by digging or turning it over. Tilling is a common gardening technique used to prepare the soil for planting or to incorporate soil amendments such as compost.

Comparison of the benefits and drawbacks of each method

Top dressing and tilling both have their benefits and drawbacks:

Top Dressing Benefits:

1. Improved soil structure: Top dressing with compost increases the amount of soil organic matter. This improves soil aeration, water infiltration, and drainage.
2. Increased nutrient availability: Compost is rich in nutrients, and top dressing with compost can improve soil fertility by increasing nutrient availability to plants.
3. Enhanced water retention: Compost helps to improve moisture retention in the soil, reducing the watering frequency.
4. Reduced erosion: Top dressing with compost can reduce soil erosion by improving soil structure and water retention.
5. Improved soil biodiversity: Compost is rich in microorganisms, which can improve soil biodiversity and support plant growth.

Top Dressing Drawbacks:

1. Slow results: Top dressing with compost takes time to show results as the compost needs to break down before it can release nutrients into the soil.
2. Limited soil penetration: Top dressing only affects the top layer of soil and does not penetrate deep into the soil.

Tilling Benefits:

1. Improved soil structure: Tilling can break up compacted soil, improving soil aeration, water infiltration, and drainage.
2. Increased nutrient availability: Tilling can aid in the incorporation of compost into the soil, hence increasing soil fertility and nutrient availability.
3. Enhanced water retention: Tilling can improve soil moisture retention, reducing the need for water.
4. Reduced weed growth: Tilling can help to reduce weed growth by uprooting weed seedlings.
5. Improved soil biodiversity: Tilling can assist to integrate compost and other organic matter into the soil, boosting soil biodiversity and plant health.

Tilling Drawbacks:

1. Soil disturbance: Tilling can disrupt soil structure, harming the soil ecology and reducing soil fertility.
2. Increased soil erosion: Tilling exposes the soil to wind and water erosion, which can exacerbate soil erosion.
3. Risk of weed growth: Tilling can also expose weed seeds to sunlight, promoting weed development.

Benefits of Adding Compost to Your Garden Soil

Adding compost to your garden soil has several benefits, including:

1. Improved soil structure

By increasing the quantity of organic matter in the soil, compost helps to enhance soil structure. Soil aeration, water infiltration, and drainage are all improved as a result. Compost also aids in soil compaction reduction, which increases the soil's ability to sustain plant development.

2. Increased nutrient availability

Compost is high in nutrients, and incorporating it into your garden soil may increase soil fertility by boosting nutrient availability to plants. Compost includes plant nutrients including nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, as well as micronutrients like calcium, magnesium, and sulfur.

3. Enhanced water retention

Compost improves soil moisture retention, minimizing the need for regular watering. This is especially significant during moments of drought when plants demand more water.

4. Reduced erosion

Compost aids in soil erosion reduction by enhancing soil structure and water retention. This is especially critical on sloping terrain where soil erosion is more prevalent.

5. Improved soil biodiversity

Compost is high in microorganisms, which aid in soil biodiversity and good plant growth. Soil microbes are essential for nutrient cycling, disease control, and soil structure preservation.

Top Dressing with Compost

How to top dress with compost

Top dressing with compost is a simple process. Here are the steps to follow:

1. Spread a layer of compost over the soil surface. The layer should be between 1/4 to 1/2 inches thick.
2. Use a rake or hoe to spread the compost evenly over the soil surface.
3. Avoid covering the stems or foliage of plants with compost.
4. Water the compost thoroughly to help it settle into the soil.

Benefits of using top dressing with compost

Top dressing with compost has several benefits, including:

1. Improved soil structure: Compost top dressing improves soil structure by increasing the quantity of organic matter in the soil.
2. Increased nutrient availability: Compost is high in nutrients, and compost top dressing can increase soil fertility by improving nutrient availability to plants.
3. Enhanced water retention: Compost improves soil moisture retention, minimizing the need for regular watering.
4. Reduced erosion: Compost top dressing can help reduce soil erosion by improving soil structure and water retention.
5. Improved soil biodiversity: Compost is high in microorganisms, which aid in soil biodiversity and good plant growth.

Best practices for top dressing with compost

Here are some best practices for top dressing with compost:

1. Use mature compost: Mature compost is fully decomposed and is less likely to burn plants or attract pests.
2. Apply compost in the spring or fall: These are the best times to apply compost as the soil is not too hot or too cold.
3. Do not disturb the soil: Top dressing should not disturb the soil. Avoid digging or tilling the soil after top dressing.
4. Avoid covering plant stems or foliage: Compost should not be applied directly to plant stems or foliage, as this can cause rot or disease.

Tilling with Compost

How to till with compost

Compost tilling is the technique of integrating compost into the soil by digging or turning it over. These are the actions to take:

1. Spread a layer of compost over the soil surface.
2. Use a tiller or shovel to mix the compost into the soil to a depth of 6 to 8 inches.
3. Avoid over-tilling as this can harm soil structure.

Benefits of using tilling with compost

Tilling with compost has several benefits, including:

1. Improved soil structure: Tilling loosens compacted soil, which improves soil aeration, water infiltration, and drainage.
2. Increased nutrient availability: Tilling can aid in the incorporation of compost into the soil, hence increasing soil fertility and nutrient availability.
3. Enhanced water retention: Tilling can enhance moisture retention in the soil, lowering the need for regular watering.
4. Reduced weed growth: By uprooting weed seedlings, tilling can assist to minimize weed development.
5. Improved soil biodiversity: Tilling can aid in the incorporation of compost and other organic matter into the soil, hence boosting soil biodiversity and promoting healthy plant development.

Best practices for tilling with compost

Here are some best practices for tilling with compost:

1. Use mature compost: Mature compost is completely digested and will not burn plants or attract pests.
2. Till to the appropriate depth: Tilling should be done 6 to 8 inches deep, which is the depth of most plant roots.
3. Avoid over-tilling: Over-tilling can harm soil structure and diminish fertility.
4. Avoid tilling when the soil is too wet: Tilling damp soil can harm the soil structure and form difficult-to-break-up clumps.

Conclusion

Composting your garden soil is one of the most effective strategies to improve soil health and promote healthy plant development. The benefits of top dressing or tilling with compost are obvious: improved soil structure, greater nutrient availability, improved water retention, reduced erosion, and improved soil biodiversity. By adhering to the best composting and gardening practices, you can build a healthy and sustainable garden ecosystem that benefits both your plants and the environment. So, add some compost to your garden soil today and reap the rewards of healthy, colorful plants!